City Cast Pittsburgh logo

4 Places for Valentine’s Day Treats in Pittsburgh

Posted on January 26, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Francesca Dabecco

Francesca Dabecco

Everything tastes better when it’s heart-shaped. (Butterwood Bake Consortium)

Everything tastes better when it’s heart-shaped. (Butterwood Bake Consortium)

📍 Lawrenceville

What’s Valentine's Day without a sticky-sweet pie? Get this heart-shaped cherry hand pie from the The Butterwood Bake Consortium. They’re known for their custom and vegan-friendly cakes, but you can’t go wrong with any of their ready-to-go goodies, like the tea or love cakes.

📍 Downtown, Lawrenceville, Mt. Lebanon, and Hazelwood

You can find any French pastry your heart desires at La Gourmondine’s four locations, but you have a limited time to get their special “Le Valentin,” a dark chocolate mousse shaped heart with a raspberry coulis center on top of a flourless chocolate biscuit. Get it February 3-14.

Find something sweet for your sweetie from Sharayahs Plant Based Treats. (@sharayahs_plantbased_pgh)

Find something sweet for your sweetie from Sharayahs Plant Based Treats. (@sharayahs_plantbased_pgh)

📍 Dormont

Can’t decide what to order? Just get the “Sweetheart Box” with raspberry flower cookies, a raspberry lemon roll, chocolate-covered strawberry mini pop tarts, and a vanilla heart cake. Did I mention the bakery is completely vegan? Order online via hotplate for pickup.

📍 Ross Township

Gluten-free eaters don’t have to compromise. Baked True North has pink love cakes, heart-shaped cookies cakes, and fresh scones. Plus, their new-ish storefront has coffee and vintage items for sale!

see more:food

Share article

Hey Pittsburgh

Stay connected to City Cast Pittsburgh and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Food & Drink

See All

The latest in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh Life Hacks

Pittsburgh Neighborhood Guide: Finding the Right Fit for Your Lifestyle

Whether you're looking for a walkable community near major employers, easy access to dining and entertainment, or a quieter neighborhood...

Pittsburgh Life Hacks

Why More Renters Are Choosing Pittsburgh's AI & Innovation Corridor

Known as the heart of Pittsburgh's innovation corridor, Bakery Square has become a destination for technology companies, healthcare organ...

Pittsburgh's BestSeptember 1

4 Things To Do in Pittsburgh in September 2026

I know, I know: it’s overplayed, it’s too sweet, “pumpkin spice” doesn’t even include real pumpkin — and yet!

Whole and sliced tomatoes sit on plates, ready for tasting below a sign that reads, “Best Tomato in Pittsburgh Contest”.
Pittsburgh, ExplainedAugust 27

Try This Pittsburgh Crossword Puzzle

A crossword puzzle all about Pittsburgh news and fun facts.

Pittsburgh's BestAugust 25

Pittsburgh’s Best Locally-Owned Pet Stores

Do you love your pet and supporting Pittsburgh businesses? Here are some local shops that have everything you need to feed, care, and play.

Lawrenceville Pet Supply shop on Butler Street. (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)
Pittsburgh's BestAugust 19

Pittsburgh’s Best Indie Movie Theaters

This single-screen space hosts special events and series like “The Show Must Go On” featuring films about show biz and its annual “13 Hou...

The Harris Theater marquee’s has its name in red neon lights on a bright blue background.
Pittsburgh's BestAugust 5

Where To Climb in Pittsburgh

If you want to top rope (aka, climb with ropes), you can use auto-belays that let you clip in and climb, or climb with a friend who’s pas...

A young person using an indoor climbing gym.
Pittsburgh's BestAugust 5

5 Things To Do in Pittsburgh in August 2026

August in Pittsburgh: Mini golf, outdoor hikes and activities, BaconBurgh, Little Italy Days, the Great American Banana Split Celebration...

Two people playing indoor mini-golf.