City Cast Pittsburgh logo

Pittsburgh’s Best Locally-Owned Pet Stores

Posted on August 21, 2023   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Francesca Dabecco

Francesca Dabecco

Lawrenceville Pet Supply shop on Butler Street. (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)

Lawrenceville Pet Supply shop on Butler Street. (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)

Do you love your pet and supporting Pittsburgh businesses? Here are some local shops that have everything you need to feed, care, and play.

🦎 Sara’s Pets and Plants (UPDATE: CLOSED, BUT RESCUE IS STILL OPEN)

If you have a lizard or bird, this shop on Main Street in Sharpsburg is for you. They also carry supplies for cats and dogs too! Sara’s Pets and Plants shares a space with the exotic pet rescue Feathers, Scales, and Tails.

Stop in to see the store’s permanent residents: Burt the bearded dragon, Mildred the alligator, Princess Peach the chicken, Petey the African gray parrot, Ruby the eclectus parrot, and Large Marge the 10-foot red-tailed boa.

🐈 Lawrenceville Pet Supply

The Butler Street store is dedicated to your four-legged friends, with more than 25 years of experience in the pet biz. You can find food, treats, leashes, toys, and more supplies.

🐾 Wagsburgh

Find nutritious foods and treats, grooming supplies, and toys at the independent shop on E. Ohio Street in East Allegheny on the North Side. Every year, Wagsburgh hosts free photo events and fundraisers for local animal rescues.

🐕 Petagogy

The independent shop on Ellsworth Avenue in Shadyside has a wide selection of healthy and natural foods, treats, and supplies for dogs and cats. The name comes from the word “pedagogy,” the art or profession of teaching, because the shop owners love learning about the best products for your furry friends.

🦜 Pretty Birds

Does your pet have wings? Find everything your flying friend needs at the family and veteran-owned Grant Avenue shop in Millvale. Plus, if you’re going away, you can board your bird there, too!

🎧 Plan the Perfect Day With Your Pittsburgh Pup
see more:pets,shopping

Share article

Hey Pittsburgh

Stay connected to City Cast Pittsburgh and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Pittsburgh's Best

See All
Pittsburgh's BestApril 10

Free Parties, Concerts and More NFL Draft Events in Pittsburgh

Party for the NFL Draft in Pittsburgh with a music crawl, free fan festival in Point State Park, Slappers N Bangers dance party, Pitt Blo...

NFL Draft glasses
Pittsburgh's BestApril 7

1,000 Things We Love About Pittsburgh: By the Numbers

City Cast Pittsburgh readers and listeners tell us what they love about living in Pittsburgh.

golden bridges and lights reflecting on river at night
Pittsburgh's BestMarch 31

10 Things To Do in Pittsburgh in April 2026

April in Pittsburgh: pink blooms, 412 Day, art and photo exhibits, Record Store Day deals, spring markets, NFL Draft fun, and more.

redbuds blooming along the Allegheny River on the North Shore.
Pittsburgh's BestMarch 25

10 Spring Pop-Up Markets for Shopping Local in Pittsburgh

Find vintage clothes and home decor, plants and seedlings, handmade goods, and more at these spring Pittsburgh pop-up markets.

candles with flower petals
Pittsburgh's BestMarch 18

8 Ways To Celebrate Mister Rogers’ Birthday in Pittsburgh

Celebrate the life and legacy of our favorite neighbor by visiting local landmarks, watching media, and spreading kindness.

black and white photo of Fred Rogers on the set of his children’s show in 1976
Pittsburgh's BestMarch 17

Tell Us What You Love About Pittsburgh

Help us make a list of 1,000 things we love about our city.

Help us make a list of 1,000 things we love about our city. (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)
Pittsburgh's BestMarch 13

5 Pittsburgh Stationery Shops for Cute Cards and More

Where to shop for unique greeting cards, fine paper, writing materials, and more in Pittsburgh.

Greeting cards, notepads shaped like matchboxes, colorful pens, and more at DooBoo. (Francesca Dabecco / City Cast Pittsburgh)
Pittsburgh's BestFebruary 27

10 Things To Do in Pittsburgh in March 2026

March in Pittsburgh: seed swaps, maple syrup season, Fringe Fest, Pittsburgh Indie Expo, Page’s return, Japanese films, and more.

page's neon sign